This is a sad story of what happened to a “young man” whose aspirations to become a baseball star had fallen. He was spoiled by his family whose imprint in the early years told him he can do no wrong; this is reinforced by adoring coaches, townspeople, peers and almost everyone whom he grew up with. He was going to be the next Mickey Mantle, he can do no wrong, the world owes him his superstardom; he decides not to go to college; he is recruited into the Minor Leagues;
What follows is a series of disappointments. He never makes Major League; he is shifted around from one team to another, one city to another. He cannot admit failure after all he’s the town baseball star. He tells his friends he is just waiting for a Big League Scout to Call him during the Off Season. He manages to survive selling cars and what not. He deteriorates psychologically, begins drinking a lot, becomes violent; his wife leaves him, he loses touch with reality.
Meanwhile, a murder occurs in town and law enforcement officials are sloppy, lazy and careless in sifting through the evidence. The real murderer lies and claims that our baseball star was seen arguing with the murdered woman in the tavern the night she was killed, even though no one in the tavern saw the baseball star that night. No one can miss his presence when the baseball star was around as he was usually boisterous and loud. The simple lie turned into a nightmare for our ex-athlete. His life is ruined.
Grisham concludes that the arrogance of the Prosecuting Attorney, the carelessness of the investigation and the unwillingness of law enforcement authorities to recognize and admit their mistakes had all contributed to the destruction of the young man.
Later DNA evidence proved that our baseball star was innocent, but even in the face of this evidence the Prosecuting Attorney challenges the validity of the DNA tests and demands another test of hair fibers found at the crime scene. He is shocked when the laboratory tests he demanded corroborated the first test. There simply was no DNA match. But he never apologizes, never admits a mistake.
This is a true story and Grisham deserves credit for telling this story on what can happen to an innocent person when law enforcement authorities and the Judicial System are sick and unwilling to face facts.